Two Hot Takes on Triathlon: Better Officiating, Bigger Risks, and What Makes Our Sport Special
Triathlon has an interesting relationship between its professional and amateur communities. Unlike many major professional sports, a significant proportion of the people who follow professional triathlon are also actively participating in the sport themselves. We're not just spectators. We're athletes, coaches, race organizers, volunteers, and officials. We've experienced many of the same situations we watch unfold on the professional circuit, albeit at considerably slower speeds.
That gives us a unique perspective on the sport. We understand the demands of racing, the nuances of competition, and the consequences of decisions made on the course.
Recently, I listened to an episode of the Professional Triathlon News (PTN) podcast discussing some of the biggest hot takes coming out of another season of professional Ironman racing, including the Ironman World Championships in Kona.
A couple of those discussions really stuck with me. Not necessarily because I agreed with every argument, but because I think they have implications that extend well beyond professional racing. In fact, I think some of the biggest opportunities for improvement in triathlon are happening much closer to home, particularly here in Ontario.
Here are two things I've been thinking about.
1. Triathlon Needs Better Officiating, Starting at the Grassroots Level
One of the discussions on the PTN podcast centered on officiating and the apparent disconnect between athletes, spectators, and the officials making decisions during professional races.
I think this is particularly interesting in triathlon because of the composition of our fan base.
Consider the average NFL fan. They might understand the rules of football exceptionally well, but there's a good chance they haven't run a passing route or caught a football in years. The same is true of many other professional sports. Fans can appreciate the competition without necessarily having firsthand experience participating in it.
Triathlon is different.
Many of the people watching professional racing are also spending six days a week training, travelling to competitions, and investing significant amounts of time and money into improving their own performances. They've experienced drafting situations, course congestion, penalty decisions, and the various challenges that come with racing.
They understand what they're watching because they've been there themselves.
Consequently, when an official makes a questionable drafting penalty call at a World Championship, we care. A lot.
We understand the implications of that decision because we know what it feels like to be on the receiving end of one.
The PTN discussion raised an interesting suggestion: greater transparency around who is officiating major professional races and what qualifications they bring to the event.
Imagine a World Championship broadcast introducing the officials before the race. Who are they? Where are they from? How long have they been officiating? What experience do they have at the national and international levels?
That information would provide spectators with some confidence that the people responsible for enforcing the rules have the appropriate experience and credentials.
I'd take that one step further.
What if officiating decisions themselves were more transparent?
For example, imagine a drafting penalty being called during a professional race. The athlete disagrees, the decision becomes controversial, and the broadcast is left trying to explain what happened.
What if officials wore cameras that allowed a head referee to review the footage? What if that referee could explain the decision to the broadcast audience, identify what they saw, and clarify why the penalty was upheld or overturned?
I'm not suggesting that every penalty needs a lengthy review process. But there is an opportunity to make officiating an actual part of the spectator experience rather than something that happens mysteriously in the background.
More importantly, I think we need to examine how we develop officials in the first place.
The Problem Starts With the Development Pathway
Speaking specifically about Ontario, the pathway to becoming a triathlon official involves taking an officiating course through the provincial sport organization, completing the required practical experience, and working through the relevant examinations and credentials.
From my understanding, the process itself isn't particularly complicated. Triathlon officiating doesn't necessarily involve the same degree of subjective judgment as officiating sports like basketball or football. There are certainly judgment calls involved, particularly around drafting distances and spatial positioning, but much of the work becomes easier with experience.
The bigger challenge, in my opinion, is the barrier to getting started.
I'd actually love to become a triathlon official. I spend my summers at races anyway, both as a coach and as an athlete. I understand the sport, I know the rules, and I think I'd be pretty good at it.
But getting started requires a financial investment, travel to complete the necessary training, and committing to shadowing officials at races to gain practical experience.
None of those things is unreasonable in isolation. The problem is that they all compete for the same limited resource: weekends.
As a coach, my weekends are already valuable. I'm either working at races where my athletes are competing, training myself, or racing. Giving up several summer weekends to complete practical officiating experience is a bigger commitment than it might initially appear.
And this leads to a much bigger question.
Why aren't there more sanctioned triathlon races in Ontario?
A Self-Reinforcing Problem
There are relatively few sanctioned triathlon events in Ontario compared with the potential demand for grassroots racing.
Part of the challenge is the availability of qualified officials. Without enough officials, it becomes harder to support sanctioned events. But that creates a circular problem: without enough sanctioned events, there are fewer opportunities for prospective officials to gain practical experience.
Of course, officiating is only one component of race sanctioning.
There are additional requirements involving race organization, course design, safety, and other standards that an event must meet before receiving provincial sanctioning. I'm not suggesting that these requirements should simply disappear.
However, I do think there's an opportunity to examine whether the process could be made more accessible to race organizers.
If sanctioning were easier to navigate, perhaps more organizers would be willing to pursue it. More sanctioned races would create more opportunities for practical officiating experience. More opportunities could attract more officials. And a larger pool of officials would make it easier to support the racing community.
Everybody benefits.
Who Is the Provincial Organization Actually Serving?
There's another dimension to this discussion that I think deserves attention: money.
Provincial sport organizations have financial responsibilities that extend well beyond grassroots racing. In triathlon, a significant portion of their revenue comes from age-group athletes through memberships, one-day fees, and race registrations.
A considerable portion of their expenditures, meanwhile, goes toward developing the next generation of high-performance athletes and supporting the pathway toward international competition and the Olympics.
I don't have a problem with that model.
In fact, I think it's entirely reasonable that recreational and age-group participants contribute to the development of the sport's future elite athletes. Developing the next generation of Olympic talent is important.
But I also think there's an important reciprocal responsibility.
If adult age-group athletes are providing a significant portion of the organization's revenue, those athletes should be able to see tangible evidence that their participation and financial contributions are valued.
That doesn't necessarily mean receiving direct financial benefits. It means having a healthy, accessible, well-supported amateur racing environment.
It means having enough sanctioned races to choose from. It means having qualified officials on the course. It means having an organization that makes it easier, rather than harder, for people to participate in and contribute to the sport.
I can speak to this personally. I've invested thousands of dollars in participating in provincial and national triathlon programs, including competing as a member of the national age-group team.
I understand that those contributions support a broader system, and I'm comfortable with that. But I'd also like to see some of that investment working directly toward improving the experience of the athletes who fund it.
I think there's room for both.
We can continue investing in the development of elite athletes while doing a better job of supporting the amateur community that makes much of that investment possible.
And for me, improving the accessibility of race sanctioning and expanding the pool of qualified officials would be a good place to start.
I'd genuinely like to be part of that process. Triathlon Ontario, if you're listening, I'd be happy to help.
2. Why Watching Athletes Collapse at the Finish Line Is Part of What Makes Triathlon Special
The second discussion is considerably more philosophical.
If you've watched the Ironman World Championships recently, you've probably seen athletes pushing themselves to extraordinary physical limits. Some collapse after crossing the finish line. Others stumble, fall, or require medical attention. Occasionally, athletes push so far beyond their sustainable limits that they simply cannot finish.
There's a segment of the triathlon community that doesn't particularly like this.
The argument is that races should be decided by athletic ability, tactical execution, and racing talent, rather than by which athlete is willing to push themselves to the point of physical shutdown.
I understand that perspective, but I actually disagree with it.
Within certain limits, I think this phenomenon is one of the things that makes championship-level triathlon so compelling.
The Strategic Gamble
Think about the difference between winning and losing in any professional sport.
At the highest level, the athletes and teams competing against one another are often remarkably close in ability. The margins are tiny. A fraction of a second, a single decision, or a moment of execution can determine the outcome.
In team sports, that difference often comes down to a strategic gamble.
A football team decides to go for it on fourth down. A baseball manager brings in a relief pitcher earlier than expected. A basketball team takes a risk on an aggressive defensive strategy.
Sometimes those decisions pay off. Sometimes they don't.
The point is that winning often requires taking a calculated risk that gives you a small competitive advantage, even if it introduces the possibility of a much bigger downside.
I think the equivalent happens in professional triathlon, particularly at World Championship events.
Professional athletes know their numbers extraordinarily well. They understand what power they can sustain on the bike, what pace they can maintain on the run, and how their bodies respond to different levels of physiological stress.
They spend years developing that knowledge through training and racing.
But on a World Championship day, knowing your limits isn't necessarily enough.
If you're within striking distance of a world title, you might have to do something that your training data tells you is probably unsustainable.
Maybe you ride a few watts harder than you planned. Maybe you run a few seconds per kilometre faster than your established threshold would suggest is appropriate. Maybe you decide to respond to an attack even though every physiological indicator is telling you that backing off would be the sensible decision.
You make that gamble because the potential reward is enormous.
And sometimes it works.
Other times, it doesn't.
The difference between those outcomes can be the difference between winning a World Championship and collapsing on the course.
When the Risk Becomes the Story
We've seen this play out at the highest level of the sport.
Athletes such as Taylor Knibb and Vincent Luis have demonstrated what it takes to compete at the very edge of their physical capabilities. We've also seen athletes such as Lucy Charles-Barclay experience the other side of that equation, where pushing beyond what the body can sustain results in a dramatic physical shutdown.
These are fundamentally different outcomes of the same competitive calculation.
An athlete recognizes an opportunity to win, makes a decision to increase their effort beyond what they would ordinarily consider sustainable, and accepts the risk that comes with it.
If the gamble works, they win.
If it doesn't, they might not even make it to the finish line under their own power.
I find that incredibly compelling.
At a World Championship, the difference between first and second isn't necessarily a question of who trained harder or who has the better physiological profile. Sometimes it's about who is willing to take the risk when the opportunity presents itself.
And sometimes the cost of that risk is remarkably visible.
That's part of what makes elite endurance sport so fascinating. The margins are so small, and the consequences of getting the calculation wrong can be so dramatic.
There Is a Difference Between Elite Racing and Everyday Racing
Now, before anyone interprets this as an endorsement of athletes routinely pushing themselves into dangerous situations, I want to make an important distinction.
I absolutely do not think this is something that should be encouraged at the local level.
Your average age-group athlete racing a local sprint triathlon, Olympic-distance event, or even an Ironman should not be trying to replicate what happens at the front of a World Championship.
Nor do I think that permanent injury or lasting physical damage should ever be an acceptable consequence of racing.
There is a meaningful distinction between an elite athlete making a calculated competitive gamble on the biggest day of their career and an amateur athlete putting themselves in unnecessary danger because they think suffering more automatically means racing better.
Those are not the same thing.
For the overwhelming majority of triathletes, the objective should be to execute the best possible race based on their preparation, fitness, experience, and race-day strategy.
But at the very highest level, where the world's best athletes are competing for the biggest prizes in the sport, I think there's something extraordinary about seeing the consequences of those strategic decisions play out so dramatically.
For 99.9% of triathlon racing, I want the results to reflect who was the strongest athlete on the day, who executed the best strategy, and who managed their effort most effectively.
But for that other 0.1%, when a World Championship is on the line, I think there's something uniquely compelling about the athlete who decides to take the gamble.
Sometimes that gamble produces a world champion.
Sometimes it produces a spectacular collapse.
And sometimes the difference between those two outcomes is almost impossibly small.
That's professional triathlon at its most dramatic.
Being Part of the Change We Want to See
Both of these discussions point toward something I think is important about triathlon.
We spend a lot of time talking about the professional side of the sport, but the health of triathlon ultimately depends on the people participating at every level.
We need better-supported amateur racing. We need accessible pathways for volunteers and officials. We need provincial organizations that recognize the value of their age-group membership. And we need professional racing that continues to push the boundaries of what we think is possible.
Those things aren't mutually exclusive.
In fact, they should reinforce one another.
As athletes, coaches, race organizers, and fans, we're not simply consumers of the sport. We're participants in building it.
Personally, I'd like to see more opportunities to contribute beyond coaching and racing. Becoming an official is one possibility, and there are plenty of other ways to help improve the local racing environment.
Because ultimately, if we think something in the sport needs to change, we should be willing to participate in making that change happen.
And if there's one thing I took away from these two discussions, it's that triathlon is a sport worth investing in, both at the highest level and right here in our own backyard.